122 replies to this topic

[Nvyseal]

bluerip, on May 2 2007, 09:50 PM, said:

Phil and Chris are gone. I actually thought Phil's performance was one of the best last night, but I'm not surprised America let him go. I like all of the ones that are left. This is getting tough. At some point there are no loosers. Its getting like that now. After all Daughtry didn't win however what a winner he is !

I agree, its starting to get emotional. I was sorry to see Chris go. As for Phil, he just seemed to blossom a little too late.

Also, i think chris did a better job singing tonight than he did last night

[USM]

Well that simon is a prick!!!

[bluerip]

USM, on May 3 2007, 02:28 AM, said:

Well that simon is a prick!!!

Thats his job!

[bluerip]

hmmmm, I gotta say somethin' before next weeks show.
This week was rather dull.
In prior years the shows got better at this point. That is to say that the singers didn't crap out as much. I don't know what it is about this year, but it is different. I'm wondering if something is going on behind the scene that is influencing what is going on. Its either that or they are all choking. I dunno???? Seems strange this year.
Anyone else feeling that ????

[USM]

bluerip, on May 11 2007, 07:01 PM, said:

hmmmm, I gotta say somethin' before next weeks show.
This week was rather dull.
In prior years the shows got better at this point. That is to say that the singers didn't crap out as much. I don't know what it is about this year, but it is different. I'm wondering if something is going on behind the scene that is influencing what is going on. Its either that or they are all choking. I dunno???? Seems strange this year.
Anyone else feeling that ????

Yes I do, there is usually more and closer competition at this point. Seems to have crapped out a little this year. Except this year Lakisha who was just voted off and I guess ended up 4th is from Flint Michigan. I am from Michigan and this is what kept me watching now that she is done it seems a little pointless for me. I think whatever it is that has changed things this year is comming from behind the scene!

[WFO]

bluerip, on May 11 2007, 04:01 PM, said:

hmmmm, I gotta say somethin' before next weeks show.
This week was rather dull.
In prior years the shows got better at this point. That is to say that the singers didn't crap out as much. I don't know what it is about this year, but it is different. I'm wondering if something is going on behind the scene that is influencing what is going on. Its either that or they are all choking. I dunno???? Seems strange this year.
Anyone else feeling that ????

Something is definitely off this year. Maybe the show has just run it's course and I am tired of it. I haven't really identified with any of the contestants. I just don't care this year. I'm pulling for Blake and Melinda but will either sell records? For me Carrie Underwood is the best of all previous winners. Have you heard Kelly Clarkson's new single? It sucks the nubes! Clive Davis wanted to scrap the whole album. I think he knows a thing or two about music and what will sell.

Edited by WFO, 11 May 2007 - 11:45 PM.

[Nvyseal]

Well tonights the final three, lets see how they rate

First round

Jordan: "Wishing on a Star"

Randy liked it
Paula good job
Simon Didn't like the arrangement

ME, There was no WOW factor

Blake: "Rocksanne"

Randy liked it
Paula Did her proud
Simon It was good, Not great

ME, it just didn't do it for me, Sorry

Melinda: "I Believe in you and me"

Randy It was HOT
Paula Fantastic
Randy Best performance in 4 weeks

ME, Good song for her


Second round

Jordan: "She Works Hard for the Money"

Randy hot tune
Paula fantastic
Simon Good performance

ME, Ok Im looking for originality, and i dont see it

Blake: "This Love"

Randy good vibe for him
Paula In your element
Simon Sounded Comfortable

ME, Good song for him, he did well with it

Melinda: "(I didnt catch the song name)"

Randy Great Performance
Paula We Love you
Randy Brilliant Performance

ME, Not bad, but not great


Third round

Jordan: "I Have Nothing"

Randy Best performance of the night from her
Paula Good Choice
Simon Wasn't loving it

ME, I liked it

Blake: "When I get you Alone"

Randy It was Alright
Paula Great Performance
Simon Liked it Took a risk

ME, Didnt like the song, But his performance was good

Melinda: "Im A Woman"

Randy Hot Vocal
Paula Stepped out into the spotlight
Randy Loved the Striptease - She got the Simon Award

ME, Sassy Performance Good Job

All said and done, I think we're going to have two girls in the Finals

[WFO]

Nvyseal, on May 15 2007, 09:07 PM, said:

All said and done, I think we're going to have two girls in the Finals

Hope not. I've never liked Jordan. Melinda #1 Blake #2 for me.

[brewin]

My Prediction:
1 - Blake
2 - Jordin
3 - Melinda

[chriso_86]

Well from reading Dave's little thingy about who thought what I would say Melinda will get it. She was the only one that got good ratings from everyone in all her songs.

But then again, I hate American Idol so I guess I don't know what I'm talking about. But I'm going for Malinda!!!

[bluerip]

Me: I can't tell how fickle Americans will vote. I will be surprised and sad for whoever has to go. I really like all three. I think all three will have great careers ahead of them.

Hey, chriso, if you hate it how come you watch it?

[Nvyseal]

bluerip, on May 16 2007, 05:30 PM, said:

Hey, chriso, if you hate it how come you watch it?

Hes a Closet Idol Fan

[brewin]

Well, I'm right so far. Melinda went home. I don't think anyone else predicted it besides me.

Jordin is next.

[Nvyseal]

brewin, on May 16 2007, 08:25 PM, said:

Well, I'm right so far. Melinda went home. I don't think anyone else predicted it besides me.

Jordin is next.

Thanks buddy, It comes on here in 15 minutes

[brewin]

Nvyseal, on May 16 2007, 10:44 PM, said:

Thanks buddy, It comes on here in 15 minutes

Not my fault my timezone is better than yours.